44 days later, however, authorities called it off, leaving many to speculate whether the real estate appraiser had simply run off of his own accord.

Then, six months after his vanishing, items belonging to Williams – including his fishing jacket, hunting license and a flashlight – were found by a local fisherman at Lake Seminole.

Kathy Aldredge had been a close friend of Williams’, and began to wonder over the circumstances of his death when her husband, Brian Winchester, started having an affair with Denise, Williams’ widow.

Speaking in Hulu documentary Mr. & Mrs. Murder, she explained: “To say they stabbed me in the back doesn’t even touch it. They had stabbed me in the soul.”

And Aldredge wasn’t alone in her suspicions. It turned out that Williams’ mother, Cheryl Williams, also believed that Brian and Denise had conspired to murder Mike